MESA Banner
Happiness as Redemption: Suffering in Contemporary Shia Mourning Rituals in Iran
Abstract by Hamidreza Salehyar On Session IV-19  (Death and Mourning in Iran)

On Tuesday, November 12 at 2:30 pm

2024 Annual Meeting

Abstract
Shia tradition promises divine rewards, believed to aid believers in the afterlife, for mourning the martyrdom of Shia holy figures, especially the third Shia Imam, Hossein. Yet, the young participants of Shia mourning rituals in Tehran rarely present divine rewards as their primary motivation for engaging in ritual practices. Instead, they emphasize how participating in rituals brings liveliness, material success, and internal peace to their daily lives, shifting the focus from spiritual to immediate, this-worldly benefits of mourning rituals. Given the historical centrality of the experience of suffering in Shia mourning rituals (Ayoub 1978), how could we understand these young ritual participants’ emphasis on narratives of inner peace, liveliness, and success? In this paper, I draw on the interviews I have conducted with young ritual participants during my doctoral fieldwork in Tehran. I elucidate how my interlocutors’ narratives can be understood in their relation to two competing yet intertwining discursive resources: state-sponsored Islamist activism, which prescribes positive emotions as a prerequisite for realizing particular religious-political ambitions, and secular neoliberal productivism, which promotes the self-management of emotions as a means to maximizing material advantage. The latter has been popularized in Iran since the 1990s by a secular happiness industry sponsoring a wide range of self-help publications and public seminars on positive psychology, mindfulness, and alternative therapeutic spiritualities, among other topics. I argue that my interlocutors’ narratives of this-worldly benefits of mourning rituals allow them to employ and challenge both Islamist and neoliberal discursive resources simultaneously. While suggesting a nuanced engagement with both religious and secular discourses, my interlocutors’ narratives reveal how they navigate and reinterpret these discourses to defend their participation in rituals. My interlocutors use a productivist logic to resist secular criticisms that dismiss Shia mourning rituals as irrational, melancholic, and anti-modern. Yet, their individualist interpretations challenge normative conceptions of these collective rituals. This innovative engagement with mourning rituals suggests a complex interplay between individual agency, the state, religious orthodoxy, and neoliberal logic, signifying the changing dynamics of Islamism in contemporary Iran. Works Cited: Ayoub, Mahmoud M. 1978. Redemptive Suffering in Islam: A Study of the Devotional Aspects of Ashura in Twelver Shi‘ism. Berlin: De Gruyter.
Discipline
Other
Geographic Area
Iran
Sub Area
None