MESA Banner
Historiographical Encounters: Kurdish and Kemalist Turkish Nationalists Rethink the Past in the Post-Ottoman Era
Abstract
This presentation aims at critically analyzing historical writings by Kurdish and Turkish nationalists during the 1930s who shared a common Ottoman background. Turkism and Kurdism as cultural movements had taken shape in the late-Ottoman era and particularly since the Young Turk Revolution (1908). However, it was the end of the Ottoman Empire that prompted the Turkish and Kurdish nationalists to imagine a national identity free from the strains of Ottoman nationalism. Mustafa Kemal (Ataturk) used an Islamic rhetoric during the War of Independence (1919-1923) and emphasized the Islamic fraternity of Turks and Kurds. After the foundation of the Turkish Republic; however, he expected Kurds to adopt a secular and Turkish civic identity. Feeling betrayed, Kurdish nationalists organized two major rebellions against Kemalist Turkey: the Sheikh Said (1925) and Ararat (1927-1930) Rebellions . While those rebellions failed, they seriously challenged the young Kemalist Republic. The struggle between the two rival nationalisms would continue during the 1930s. Historiography was a major component of the struggle. Ataturk was personally involved in a history-writing project which presented Turks as the primary makers of world history. Known as the Turkish History Thesis, this new historiographical vision emphasized pre-Islamic Turkish history rather than the Islamic-Ottoman one. A similar but rival attempt to re-write history from nationalist perspective was led by exiled Kurdish nationalists of Turkey in Syria and Lebanon under the French mandate during the 1930s. After briefly introducing the late-Ottoman precedents of both Turkist and Kurdist attempts to view the past through the ethnic terms, this presentation will compare and contrast the two rival historiographical projects during the 1930s. I will put them in perspective by clarifying the political events as well as racial and linguistic debates that shaped Turkish and Kurdish historiographical arguments. For my presentation, I make use of primary sources including textbooks, magazine articles, conference proceedings, and memoirs from the time period in Kurmanji Kurdish, Turkish, as well as French languages.
Discipline
History
Geographic Area
Turkey
Sub Area
None