MESA Banner
The Cost of Cleaning: Tracing the Slow Violences of Sanitization at COP27 and COP28
Abstract
Garbage can be a highly mobilizing political object. When waste infrastructure breaks down – whether due to state failure, collective action, environmental crises, or some combination of these forces – waste disrupts the flow of everyday life. Piles of rubbish are noticeable, not only as a visible marker of disorder, but also as odorous and viscerally revulsive offenses to the senses. As Sophia Stamatopoulou-Robbins illustrates, exposure to waste can closely index governance levels in a given territory (2019, 4). But what about the costs of systems operating exactly as designed? Even when waste is invisible and unnoticeable to some, its management may still rely on structural violence. In this paper, I argue for attention to waste and systems of discarding not only in moments of disruption but also in times and spaces of structured cleanliness. Based on ethnographic fieldwork at three consecutive UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) Conference of Parties (COP) events and interviews with actors in states that have hosted the COP, I lay out a framework of “sanitization,” in which contentious objects like waste are rendered discursively and materially nonpolitical. Focusing on the waste practices in Sharm el-Sheikh and in Dubai during COP27 and COP28 respectively, I show how subjectivities shape experiences of waste and its management and how local actors can coopt, leverage, and resist sanitization.
Discipline
Political Science
Geographic Area
Egypt
UAE
Sub Area
None