MESA Banner
On States and Estates: Writing the Provinces into the Social and Economic History of Qajar Iran
Abstract
This paper will argue that the management of family estates by provincial elites in Qajar Iran was the single most significant factor shaping social and economic change in local communities. The approach I present in this paper offers a framework for writing the experiences of the provinces into the historiography of the Qajar period. For nearly forty years, the social and economic history of Qajar Iran has revolved around the concept of “modernization.” Does the steady increase in production and foreign trade reflect an era of slow economic growth as Gad Gilbar and Charles Issawi maintained? Or did the reorientation of Iran’s economy towards the export of raw materials simply place Iran in a position of dependency on foreign industrial powers as John Foran has argued? With a growing interest in the varied experiences of Iranian provincial communities in the process of social and economic change, it is now clear that there are major problems with both lines of argumentation. First is the lack of agency granted to Iranians in reshaping the world around them. These works treat “modernization” as a menacing outside force reshaping Iran seemingly by its own will. Secondly, the level of analysis remains tied to the state at a time when the poorly integrated Qajar Empire did not possess anything like a unified political economy. In provincial communities, the state represented just one of several players in the reorientation of local economies. This paper will explore the influence of another important factor in the so-called “modernization” of Qajar Iran through the experience of a provincial community in Kirman. Using local histories, geographical writings, Persian language travelogues, governmental reports, and the observations of foreign administrators, I will discuss the adaptive strategies employed by leading members of the provincial elite. In Kirman, like in other provincial communities, powerful locally rooted families, and not the state, dominated local social, political, and economic institutions. Changes in the strategies of household estate management, in an atmosphere of intense factional competition, drove the commercialization of Kirman’s agriculture, a boom in carpet manufacturing, and an unprecedented level of urban-rural economic integration over the course of the late 19th century. Using the lens of estate management reveals how powerful elements of Iranian provincial communities mediated outside pressures to reshape the world around them, as opposed to conventional views of Qajar Iran as a unified political economy or a passive victim of external forces.
Discipline
History
Geographic Area
Iran
Sub Area
19th-21st Centuries