MESA Banner
Charitable Futures and Charitable Pasts: Entrepreneurship, Charity and Poverty in Contemporary Turkey
Abstract
As the recent financial crisis rippled through world economies, debates were reinvigorated about the immorality of global capitalism and the free market economy. While greedy financiers and inept economists were crucified in the media, the ideal of entrepreneurship arose as the moral panacea to rising extremism and poverty. Newsweek declared in “Economics versus Extremism” that overregulated economies that “stifled entrepreneurship” were to blame for Islamist extremism. In turn, charitable entrepreneurs were hailed as the panacea to the ills of poverty and underdevelopment with the decline of the welfare state; the April 2010 Obama summit with Middle Eastern entrepreneurs is a good example of this trend. Since the 1980s, Turkey has continuously witnessed the formation and rise of the Anatolia-based yet nationally and internationally well-connected entrepreneurs. Several research studies have traced this historical process that is closely intertwined with the developing power of a pious electoral base that expresses diverse and at times contradictory responses to the possibility of EU accession, economic transformations, JDP policies, and the changing tapestry of Turkish daily life as AVMs (shopping malls) and Turkish television serials become national pastimes. Understudied and underexamined in current research is the concomitant rise of charitable associations that are largely founded by conservative entrepreneurs and supported by this conservative electoral base. Charitable associations provide spaces where donors, volunteers, and donees increasingly rethink and reformulate the meanings and practices of charitable giving, Turkish state, daily life, piety, and Islamic practice. They also become places where the conservative entrepreneur and donors fulfill their religious obligations and form charitable communities. Based on ongoing ethnographic research in Turkey, this paper will examine the contours of charitable giving and nostalgia for an idealized Ottoman rule as both a response to, and a result of corrupt governance and the decline of the welfare state. Under the current Justice and Development Party (JDP) government, welfare provision and associations that spearheaded such provision became effective strategies to consolidate neoliberalism, globalization, and the JDP project of joining the European Union. Hence, if the state is taken to be a discursive, diffuse, and representational construct, then the delegation of poor relief to conservative entrepreneurs and civil society organizations increasingly support and enable both the representational and real existence of the neoliberal state. Ironically, though, charitable giving also provides a space where the neoliberal state is questioned, analyzed, and challenged.
Discipline
Anthropology
Geographic Area
Turkey
Sub Area
Middle East/Near East Studies