MESA Banner
Beneath and Beyond Gender and Sexuality: Cultures of Friendship, Sociality, and the Erotic in the Modern Middle East

Panel 184, 2016 Annual Meeting

On Saturday, November 19 at 2:00 pm

Panel Description
In the nineteenth and twentieth centuries across the Middle East, imperial, modernizing, authoritarian, and colonial states tried to regulate, shape, and discipline the gender, bodies, sexuality, and desire of their subjects. Rather than taking such blueprints and visions at face value, this panel considers a versatile range of public and private responses and challenges to these tendencies put forward by both men and women. Our focus is broad and the papers explore both how activists and writers engaged with new gender discourses and ideals in the press as well as the private and semi-private homosocial, homoerotic, and sexual side of modern friendships and relationships. We believe that this textured and unexplored history is best understood by looking at the less structured spaces of leisure and forms of association such as private clubs and societies, and in tandem, by investigating how the written word was used by groups and individuals to upset dominant conceptions of gender. In other words, this panel highlights individuals and institutions at times involved with and in proximity to, but not necessarily part of states and other centers of power. We therefore intentionally accentuate and favor private sexual and erotic articulations, representations, and practices in an attempt to move beyond the novel disciplinary, state-sponsored, and nationalist discoursers and dominant visions of masculinity, femininity, and sexuality. In fact, one of the goals of this panel is to circumvent such discourses by redirecting attention to the ways in which men and women responded to, complicated, and at times subverted the dictates of modern and normative gender roles, sexuality, and friendship. By drawing parallels and pointing out differences, the four papers on this panel take a cross regional approach and move from late Ottoman Istanbul to twentieth century Cairo via Baghdad. From different geographical vantage points and drawing on versatile material, the four papers explore homosocial bonds of friendship in the almost exclusively male space of Ottoman sports clubs in Istanbul; The role of women in the formation of the Iraqi effendiyya seen through the feminist ideas and models of womanhood of Paulina Hassun, editor of Iraq's first women's magazine; The private homoerotic photographs of an Egyptian athlete, which offer up a subversion of the normative and a reformulation of gender and the erotic in the private sphere; And "cruising," homosoical, and homoerotic desire in the prose fiction of the Iraqi writer Dhu al-Nun Ayyub.
Disciplines
History
Participants
  • Prof. Haytham Bahoora -- Discussant
  • Dr. Murat C. Yildiz -- Presenter
  • Dr. Noga Efrati -- Presenter
  • Mr. Pelle Valentin Olsen -- Organizer, Presenter
Presentations
  • Dr. Murat C. Yildiz
    In the midst of the First World War, Abdurrahman Robenson, an Ottoman soldier stationed in Erzurum, sent a letter to his friend Ali Sami, the president and founder of the Galatasaray Physical Training Club, in Istanbul. In the letter, Abdurrahman juxtaposed descriptions of his experiences in the army, friendship with Sami, and his unwavering loyalty to the Galatasaray club. Abdurrahman writes, “I always carry the [Galatasaray] club medals with me on my chest. I will take them with me into war. If I die, I will be buried with them. Long live Galatasaray (yaşasın Galatasaray).” Abdurrahman’s letter offers insights into the evolving mores of male honor, the homosocial bonds connecting members of sports clubs and the centrality of club affiliation to the identity of many Ottoman male subjects. During the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, Ottoman Muslim, Christian, and Jewish citizens and foreign residents of Istanbul established a plethora of sports clubs around the imperial capital. From Beyoğlu to Tatavla to Vefa, young men signed up to become members of their neighborhood sports clubs. These voluntary associations, which were ethnically and religiously homogenous and almost exclusively homosocial private organizations, attracted Istanbulites from an expanding middle class who wanted to train their bodies, exercise, compete, socialize, have fun, and establish friendships with likeminded young men. Drawing from a diverse array of sources, such as photograph albums, letters, sport club records, government reports, newspapers, memoirs, and illustrated magazines, as well as oral histories, this paper examines the intimate bonds that members of these clubs cultivated. In order to explore the connections between male affection, homosocial bonds, and communal identity in late Ottoman Istanbul, the paper will examine the ways in which young men, such as Abdurrahman, competed on the pitch, hung out at the club, poised for photographs, explored the city and its surrounding environs, took public transportation, exercised, and swam in the sea. The argument advanced is based on multi-lingual archival research, and is part of a broader project on the creation of a shared sports culture among Turks, Armenians, Jews, and Greeks in the late Ottoman Empire.
  • Dr. Noga Efrati
    The way the educated middle class in Iraq of the 1920s, often referred to as Effendiyya, engaged new discourses about gender has received little attention in scholarly literature. The voice of Iraq's first generation of "new" women is especially absent. My paper will focus on Paulina Hassun, editor of "Layla", the first Iraqi women's magazine. Born in 1895 to an Iraqi father from Mosul, and a Palestinian mother, Paulina Hassun returned to Iraq in the beginning of the 1920s. Her aim was to establish the first women's organization and the first women's magazine in Iraq. Accounts of the hardships she encountered create the impression that Iraq was not yet ready for her feminist ideas and the model of womanhood she projected. Based on her writings, the period press, and archival materials my paper will offer an in-depth view of her experience and challenge this understating.
  • Mr. Pelle Valentin Olsen
    “Cruising Baghdad” examines masculinity and sexuality in interwar Iraq through forms of homosocial and homoerotic notions of friendship and relationships. Moving from the homosocial to the explicitly homoerotic, this paper engages with both sanctioned and normative friendships and relationships as well as more illicit, nonnormative, and unsanctioned practices and desires. It turns to literature as an important repository of critical and alternative voices as well as alternative visions of sexuality, masculinity, state, and society. More specifically, it examines and discusses these questions through the fictional and autobiographical writings of Iraqi communist, teacher, and prose writer Dhu al-Nun Ayyub. Ayyub was born in Mosul and graduated from the Higher Teachers Training College in Baghdad, which had been established in 1923 and which where to educate many prominent Iraqi intellectuals. He died in 1988 in Vienna. Ayyub is considered to be one of the pioneers of Iraqi fiction and is recognized for the satirical and often sociopolitical flavor of his works, but the literary quality if his works is often described as less mature and less developed than the works of the 1950s generation. The homosocial, homoerotic, and sexual themes in Ayyub’s writings have received little attention. Only one critical work in Arabic exists on Ayyub’s eight volume confessional autobiography. This paper focuses primarily on the short stories published in the collection Sadiqi (My Friend, 1938) and argues that the sexualized description and celebration of the male body in Ayyub’s short stories represent instances of homosocial and homosexual desire. Ayyub’s short stories also highlight the ways in which the disciplinary and militarist discourses of the state in interwar Iraq were challenged from a number of different positions and by a number of different actors. In other words, this paper suggests, without reducing sexual desire to resistance, that Ayyub’s short stories raise important questions about how Iraqi men responded to, complicated, and subverted the nationalist and militaristic body image propagated by the state as well as normative sexuality. Finally, this paper hopes to open up a window onto our understanding of masculinity, male culture and friendship as well as relation(ships) in an almost exclusively homosoical public sphere in which friendship, leisure, and social relations were gendered and constructed along same-sex lines. In tandem, “Cruising Baghdad” attempts to visualize the relationship between, friendship, sexuality, space, and leisure in the modern city of Baghdad.