Arab Revolts: A Critical View on the Narratives of Freedom and Authoritarianism, Panel II
Panel 179, 2011 Annual Meeting
On Saturday, December 3 at 5:00 pm
Panel Description
The ousting of president Ben Ali from Tunisia, the battle for Egypt, the numerous manifestations asking for economic, social and political reform in Yemen, Algeria and Jordan, have puzzled many observers. What prompted these changes? Was it the self-immolation of Tunisian Mohammed Bouazizi? Was it the death of Khaled Said under torture in Egypt? Was it the repressive nature of authoritarian regimes or was it the inequality and poverty throughout the region that were not only hitting the poor but also the middle classes? Questions abound and we have to admit that a few of us saw this landslide change coming.
As the events throughout the region unfold, a few recurring narratives are gaining prominence in the bid to 'understand' and 'frame' the episode. While the international media suddenly 'discovered' Middle Eastern dictators (other than the usual suspects), academics had trouble situating the failure of what until recently were seen as entrenched authoritarian systems. What emerged was the idea that corrupt rulers had harvested the economic benefits of the reforms and, in their greed, forgot to spread the wealth to their populations. This narrative is off course focusing, like much of the political and social science literature on the region, on 'the regime', its actions and agency. It however obfuscates the new "private" arenas and public spaces in which economic and social change was long articulated through new forms of expression by young men and women in the Middle East. This ranges from sustained forms of socio-economic protests to neighborhood associations and use of new media (virtual press, blogs, youtube,...) as well as specific forms of culture (hip pop culture and rap music). Investigating these arenas would provide alternatives to top down accounts about political authoritarianism and will bring shed light on new forms of political and social change, new modes of sociability, gender and human agency
This panel wants to re-frame the debate on political change that is occurring by addressing the following questions: (1) To what extent has the focus on 'regimes' obfuscated the major changes that the Arab world was/is going throughr (2) To what extent have the policies of reform induced the uprisingsr (3) How have the human subjects in the Arab world challenged their description as passive objects of authoritarian rule and/or religioni How were/are new political alliances and forms of struggle being developed and, (4) What is the role of gender in these movementse
Mubarak spirit on its way to its Creator met with two other spirits: Nasser's and Sadat's. They asked: Poison or bullet? He answered: Facebook. Maria Fahmy
As millions in Cairo were calling for regime change, bloggers, rappers and facebook(ers) were articulating their visions of the new order to emerge. These virtual spaces of revolution have been sites for “deliberations” about the meanings of citizenship and rights by a new generation of politically engaged yet marginalized urban youth. I argue that the use of the new social media has not only been central to the rise of discursive communities and social networks, but also to the formation of the new subjectivities of Arab youth, as agents of social change. Are we witnessing the rise of a “revolutionary” virtual public sphere? In this paper I will answer this question by exploring two places in which youth’s desire for new modes of sociability and political expression were enacted under the form of political mobilization and action. I propose a content analysis of women’s blogs in Egypt and Moroccan rap. My goal is to show the limits of the rhetoric of political freedom, as a unique lens to understand the current appraisals in North Africa and the Middle East, by showing how these freedoms have been articulated by young men and women in the realm of 1) “responsible” citizenship and social solidarity; 2) plural identities; 3) ethical economic practices and demands for social welfare. Hence, by stressing regime change in ongoing protests in the Middle East, this generation of revolutionaries is requesting the end of an area in which corrupt local elites seem to be the expression of global capitalist interests and interventions.
Authoritarian Regimes, Religion and Revolts: The Case of Algeria
Issam Aburaya
The major purpose of this essay is to explore the transformation of the Algerian Islamic movement from a body that focused mainly on social, religious and cultural reform in the 1960s into a radical (and very popular) political opposition in the late 1980s. More specifically, I contend to highlight the connections between the structural characteristics of the post-colonial Algerian political regime, its policies and contradictions that led eventually to the mass rebellion in October 1988 followed by political liberalization measures on one hand and the changing nature of the Algerian Islamic opposition, its shifting aims and strategies on the other. I aim to demonstrate this by highlighting the two major factors that turned the Algerian Islamic movement into a significant force in the mass rebellion against the authoritarian regime in October 1988 and subsequently into the main benefactor of the first fair and democratic municipal and national elections in postcolonial Algeria (1990-1991).
I argue these factors were: First, the Islamic movement’s effective cooptation of the legacy, symbolism and aims of the Algerian revolution and the national liberation struggle which in the Algerian consciousnesses are tantamount to national pride, egalitarianism and social justice. Second, the Movement’s impressive capacity of combining organic and modern mobilizing structures. Of special interest for this essay is what is depicted in the vernacular Algerian language the Huma (Le quartier). The Huma allowed Islamic movement to produce an extensive and sophisticated communication networks in its opposition to the current ruling elites. This is in addition to its successful combination of universal Islamic ideals and values with local identities and connections such as the family and the neighborhood
One of the most significant developments in the ongoing Jasmine Revolution has been the emergence of Tunisian rappers as political actors. Much has been made of the use of social networking websites and services in the recent upheavals, with many taking issue with the overemphasis on American-invented social networking sites. However it is undeniable that throughout the Tunisian uprising, music videos and video messages of support have been disseminated via Facebook, YouTube, MySpace and the like. Tunisian hip hop heads have demonstrated themselves to be particularly adept at harnessing the web, deftly skirting government-imposed internet censorship, to establish a community that is at once virtual, tangible, and very much attuned to the country’s vicissitudes. The Tunisian rapper El Général, author of songs such as“Tounes bledna” (Tunisia’s our homeland), attracted the ire of the Tunisian government following the release of the hard-hitting song “Rayes lebled” (The President of the Country). During the height of the uprising that first spread from Sidi Bouzid, Tunisian security forces arrested the rapper on January 3, 2011 and he was held and eventually released by the Ministry of the Interior later. Meanwhile, the public could track his detention via his Facebook updates and interviews given by his family to the international press. Tunisia’s biggest rapper, Balti, recorded and spread a statement of support with regard to his protesting countrymen via Facebook shortly after Ben Ali’s ouster. Ultimately I will examine the ways in which Tunisian hip hop offers an important, new chapter in the short history of Maghrebi hip hop. If we accept that these Tunisian rappers have become political actors in the country, it would behoove us to determine to what extent they themselves embrace or refuse this role? Indeed, what does it mean to produce street rap (with its heavy connotations of the “Arab Street”) in the midst of civil unrest and veritable chaos? This paper will engage the concept of Arab Revolt by examining these questions. Do revolutions have a soundtrack? Did/does Tunisia have one?
In light of social upheaval and protests in both Tunisia and Egypt, one cannot ignore their power and the yearning of Arab youth for political expression. Many argue that the current events in the Arab world would be replicated in other countries such as Algeria, Morocco, and Yemen. However, I argue that despite the outcomes of the revolution in Tunisia and Egypt, Morocco remains one of the most complex countries in which it would be difficult to see organized massive uprisings. This is because one needs to better understand the different contexts and dynamics in which social movements germinate and operate.
While Moroccan youth refuse to engage in the “silencing of the self” as a way to internalize repression and exclusion, they are also caught in the dilemma of co-optation and the pitfall of irrelevance. There are intrepid attempts by youth activists to assert themselves, including the formation of several youth organizations calling for youth civic and political empowerment. Yet, youth continue to be excluded from the position of political power. One should cast a critical perspective on the “menace of exclusion” and state policies of bricolage towards youth demands. The inadequacy of state policies in addressing youth issues or including them in policy formation processes is among the main factors that trigger discontent. With the increasing strength of reactionary government policies, and the parallel focus on stability discourse, youth issues in Morocco were increasingly ignored and the distinctive role of youth in policy never has been seriously considered.
The contribution youth movements are making to political and social change includes the call for youth political inclusion. Youth in Morocco are learning how to shutter the symbols of power that most Moroccans revere, and continue to push the boundaries to have their voice heard. This paper will offer an in-depth look at the youth consistent involvement in demanding political change, and their work as activists in the political and civic milieu in Morocco. It will also examine state policies that respond to youth demands, their effectiveness and success, and examine how youth view these policies in light of the current state of affairs in the Arab world. To what extent would youth be successful in altering and changing the political reality in Morocco? And what is the nature of this change? are two questions that this response will also try to answer.