MESA Banner
Environmental Histories of Qajar Iran

Panel 128, 2010 Annual Meeting

On Saturday, November 20 at 11:00 am

Panel Description
Beginning in the nineteenth century, imperialism and the expansion of the world economy spurred the transformation of natural environments in the Middle East. This panel addresses this encounter between empire, the global economy, and nature in the context of modern Iran. It consists of two papers that approach the little explored subject of the environmental history of Iran. The papers in the panel situate environmental change in Iran within broader regional and global contexts, as well as incorporating original source materials overlooked in existing scholarship in the field. The first paper draws upon Persian travel accounts about Central Eurasia to explore the Qajar attempt to order and reclaim the steppes of the Qara Qum Desert. It argues that the gathering of information about the steppes was part of a larger global imperial interest in converting environments but that it was ultimately shaped through the material encounter with the desert. The second paper on scarcity and social conflict considers the origins of a string of famines that occurred in Iran during the second half of the nineteenth century. It examines government policy towards the shortage of grain and international humanitarian efforts to alleviate famine in Iran. In addition, the paper contends that the scarcity of natural resources incited rural conflict and urban protests across the country and gradually politicized the population.
Disciplines
History
Participants
  • Dr. Edmund Burke III -- Discussant, Chair
  • Dr. Arash Khazeni -- Organizer, Presenter
  • Prof. Ranin Kazemi -- Organizer, Presenter
Presentations
  • Dr. Arash Khazeni
    Across the Black Sands and the Red: Travel Writing, Nature, and the Reclamation of the Eurasian Steppe, c. 1850 Through a reading of nineteenth-century Persian travel narratives, this paper locates the history of Iran and Central Eurasia within the context of the recent literature on global frontier processes, and the encounter between empire and nature. It argues that Persianate travel books (safarnama) about Central Eurasia were part of the imperial project to order and reclaim the natural world and were forged through the material encounter with the steppes. Far from a passive act of collecting information and more than merely an extension of the observer's preconceptions, description was essential to the expansion and preservation of empire. While there exists a vast literature on Western geographical and ethnographic representations of the Middle East, building on the critiques of Edward Said in Orientalism and Culture and Imperialism, only recently have scholars begun to mine contacts that took place outside of a Western colonial framework and within an Asian setting. Based on an analysis of Riza Quli Khan Hidayat's Sifaratnama-yi Khvarazm, the record of an expedition sent from the Qajar Dynasty to the Oxus River in 1851, the following pages explore the nineteenth-century Muslim "discovery" of the Eurasian steppe world. The Khvarazm expedition set out to define imperial boundaries and reclaim to the desert, but along the way it found a permeable "middle ground" in between empires marked by trans-frontier and cross-cultural exchanges, such as trade and pilgrimage.
  • Prof. Ranin Kazemi
    Late nineteenth-century Iran was characterized by agro-environmental crises and social protests. Furthermore, European powers, local notables, as well as the provincial and central governments all vied for control of the natural resources. This paper inquires into the origins of a string of urban protests that occurred in 1871-1892. It argues, among other things, that the twin processes of capitalism and imperialism undermined the moral economy of agricultural production and resource use in a semi-feudal social system. The paper traces the growth of dissatisfaction from the early 1870s when the Qajar state enacted a series of reforms aimed at centralizing government bureaucracy. As the central government raised taxes on the provinces, the governors and the landed elites engineered massive hoarding and price gouging in essential goods such as grain. Meanwhile the outbreak of locusts and epidemics, as well as a string of chronic famines wreaked havoc throughout the country. The government was, however, unable to quickly or systematically alleviate public suffering. Instead, it began from the late 1880s to grant European firms a number of concessions over agricultural production, forests, mines, and fisheries. The protests over government policy came to a head in the Anti-Tobacco Regie Movement of 1891-1892 when a nationwide embargo on the use of tobacco succeeded to reverse a British tobacco concession. In this paper, therefore, I look at the political ecology of commercial agriculture and its relations to conflict between foreign powers, the government, local notables, and the protesters. For this reason, this paper draws from theories of political ecology developed by environmental historians such as Alf Hornborg, J. R. McNeill, and Joan Martinez-Alier. In writing this paper, I have drawn from eighteen months of archival research in England and Iran. The majority of the sources I am utilizing have not been used by other scholars.