MESA Banner
Paths of Empowerment: Transforming Gender Dynamics in Egypt

Panel 105, 2010 Annual Meeting

On Saturday, November 20 at 08:30 am

Panel Description
Despite years of concerted effort by dedicated leaders and policy analysts, the gender gap is still extremely wide. One reason for this is an overemphasis on top-down strategies. But research shows that for empowerment to be meaningful, strategies need to actively involve the stakeholders (Hur, 2006). This type of social change involves sharing, inspiring, participating, learning, joining; in short it requires engagement at all stages of the process. The 2005 UN report entitled "Taking Action: Achieving Gender Equality and Empowering Women" suggested a number of important, practical strategies that governments could take to achieve gender equality and empower women. But the most interesting ideas in this report were those inspired by real women who had mobilized and directly taken on the great challenge of transforming gender dynamics in their own communities. Such stories are not only inspiring, but they contribute to the shared body of knowledge that informs best practices in public policy and social movements. This panel shares the inspiring stories of communities in Egypt who have taken action in creative, active and liberatory ways, and argues for a radical shift towards grassroots activism as a means of lasting gender change. Hur, Mann Hyung. 2006. "Empowerment in Terms of Theoretical Perspectives: Exploring a Typology of the Process and Components across Disciplines." Journal of Community Psychology, 34 (5): 523-540. United Nations Millenium Project Task Force on Education and Gender Equality. 2005. "Taking Action: Achieving Gender Equality and Empowering Women." http://www.unmillenniumproject.org/documents/Gender-complete.pdf
Disciplines
Anthropology
Political Science
Sociology
Participants
  • Dr. Helen M. Rizzo -- Chair
  • Mrs. Heather Browne -- Organizer
  • Maro Youssef -- Presenter
  • Ms. Leslie Lewis -- Presenter
Presentations
  • Maro Youssef
    Egyptian Film During The 1950s and 1960s: Class tensions, Nationalism and Gender relations. Egyptian society was permanently transformed after the 1952 Revolution. These changes are visible through the development of gender roles portrayed in films of the era of President Gamal Abdel Nasser, who took office in 1954. During his tenure from 1954 to 1970 he advocated for nationalism, anti-imperialism, socialism and gender role transformations. Egyptian films began to embody the essence of gender roles and relations of the period. Egyptian popular films such as Memoirs of a Student/ zekrayat talebah (1962), The Empty Pillow/ el wasada al khalya (1957), Mother of The Bride/ umm al 'arusah (1963), and A Film For Men Only/ film lel rejal faqat (1964), represented Egyptian attitudes of the 1950s and 60s towards money, education, love and the increased presence of women in the public sphere. The films are a miniature portrait of the contradictions and upheaval of the Nasser years. My research focuses on the depiction of women in 1950s and 60s films and the driving factors behind this depiction. What caused gender norms to drastically change during this periodo Did conventions of filmmaking differ from the 1930s and 1940s0 Was there a new generation of filmmakersr Did women's lives naturally change from mothers of the state to daughters of the state over a twenty-year periodr To what extent did the state interfere with gender norms and to what extent did it try to control women's bodies through state interventione There remains a gap in both feminist and film literature when it comes to the sudden transformation of gender norms and women's roles within the state. My analysis of the four films mentioned earlier shows how the depiction of nationalism, gender tensions and class tensions tracks with broad social changes in Egypt and shows the interplay between the two.
  • Ms. Leslie Lewis
    Popular conjecture and academic theorizing about Middle Eastern women's agency has a long history. Early writings reinforced essentializing, orientalizing stereotypes by portraying women as passive victims both of patriarchal systems and individual (stereotypically brutal) men (Mohanty 1988). Subsequent research sought to uncover instances of women's agency in the face of constraints on their freedom (Abu-Lughod 1986; Atiya 1982; Davis 1983; Early 1993; Fernea 1985; Wikan 1991). They focused on identifying the conceptual and practical resources available to women, and the ways that women appropriate them in support of their own interests. Women were seen as resisting male-centered cultural hegemony either by carving out space apart from men (e.g., in language and poetry, weaving, or cult possession), or by enacting small rebellions within gender-unequal structures, acts which often had the unintentional and paradoxical effect of reproducing the very inequality they were meant to upset (see Boddy 1989; Brusco 1995; Hale 1987; Hegland 1998; Macleod 1991; Torab 1996). In the case I will describe, a number of pious Muslim women have improved their life circumstances, and in many cases, improved those of other women, not by resisting dominant norms, but by adopting and perfecting the very ideals and practices that on the surface appear to limit them. A growing grassroots Islamic piety movement has taken root Egypt over the past few decades. Women have been at the forefront of this, fostering religious education and life transformation among growing cadres of women. Significantly, the forms of practice and belief they adopt: dominant, orthodox, textual, "masculine" brand of Islamic practice, lend them a new legitimacy and levels the spiritual and social playing field. Many of the women in this movement "do" piety better, even, than their male counterparts. They become models of pious practice, spending hours every day in prayer, study and acts of da'wa and charity. The legitimacy of the form, and the women's self-discipline and accomplishment, place them above scrutiny. And yet, the effects for individual women, and for larger society, are complicated. The creed the pious women have embraced, and the practices they have perfected, have opened up new avenues for spiritual, social and psychological expression and gratification. At the same time, they have circumscribed their actions in a variety of ways. This paper will examine this complex, complicated moral and religious project, its sociopolitical implications, and the benefits and drawbacks for individual women's lives.