Sport, Society, and Conflict in the Middle East and North Africa
Panel 077, 2010 Annual Meeting
On Friday, November 19 at 04:30 pm
Panel Description
This panel will explore the significance of sport in the representation and production of identity in the Middle East and North Africa. Specifically, it considers the playing, watching, and representation of sport through film and writing as important elements in the constitution or confounding of national narratives in the region. Scholars have in recent years increasingly noted the importance of sport in the production of political, social, and cultural identities in other parts of the world. For those areas formerly colonized by Europeans, athletic competition has long represented both an opportunity to challenge former colonizers and to assess modern national projects. Curiously, however, relatively little scholarly work has been done on the intersection of sport and society in the Middle East and North Africa. For example, despite the enormous popularity of sports throughout the Arab world, historians, sociologists, and political scientists have mostly ignored the central importance of athletic competition in the region, or the role it plays in the formation of local, national, and regional identities in most MENA countries.
This panel seeks to address this gap in the literature by demonstrating not only the importance of athletic competition in the region, but also the broader implications of this particularly popular cultural practice for understanding and re-evaluating more commonly studied political, social, and cultural developments . By using a myriad of sources, including media reports in Arabic, Hebrew, English, French, memoirs and interviews in several languages, film, blogs, and government sources, the papers in this panel illustrate a deep and complex relationship between sports and narratives of colonial pasts, postcolonial presents, resistance, race, and gender. From football in Morocco and Egypt to boxing and martial arts in Tunisia, Egypt, and Israel, the panel demonstrates that sports are implicated in both subtle and profound ways to broader concerns; in both the official halls of power, and also in the more "popular" settings of the local training facility, stadium, movie theatre, and street. By doing so, these papers shed new light on the mutually constitutive nature of sporting competition and constantly shifting narratives of nation, state, and society, and argue that discussions of the latter in the MENA cannot be fully understood without consideration of the immense popularity of sport.
Disciplines
Participants
-
Dr. Shaun Lopez
-- Organizer, Presenter, Chair
-
Dr. Tamir Sorek
-- Presenter
-
Dr. Robert B. Lang
-- Presenter
Presentations
-
Arab sport in Israel is publicly presented by its major actors as an integrative sphere, and Arab athletes usually distance themselves from nationalist overtones or political protest. Israeli Boxing, which is dominated athletically and administratively by Arabs is even an extreme example of this tendency. This paper juxtaposes the integrative discourse produces by Arab boxer and functionaries with the life story of Hamze Yones. In 1963 Hamze Yunes was a rising boxing star and represented his Israeli sports association, Beitar, in international competitions. Eight years later, in 1971, he was captured in the Mediterranean Sea while commanding a group of Palestinian naval guerillas on their way to kidnap Israeli soldiers. In 1974 he became a Palestinian national hero after a legendary escape from an Israeli jail to Lebanon. Hamze's fascinating life story from Israeli boxing star to Palestinian guerrilla is not only good material for a Hollywood blockbuster movie, it is also highly interesting as a case study that challenges the conventional linkage between Arab sport and politics Israel. Hamze's narrative ties his attraction for boxing to the humiliation of Arab men under the Israeli Military Government (1948-1966), implying that boxing was a combative practice more than a channel for integration. Based on Hamze's memoirs published in 1999 and interviews with his family members, the article contrasts the two diametrically opposed discourses and discusses the reasons for Hamze's exceptionality.
-
Dr. Robert B. Lang
Hichem Ben Ammar's "J'en ai vu des etoiles" records and recounts the stories of several Tunisian boxers from the 1920s to the present, and in so doing, develops a thesis about loss, regret, and anger. The film bears witness to the disappearance of a world, and what emerges from the accounts of his boxers and their trainers, managers, referees, friends, fans, and sons and wives, is a kind of allegory describing Tunisia's colonial past and the rocky road of decolonization that leads to the present. In the words of one retired boxer, as he stands before the former gym of the legendary trainer and amateur boxer Rezgui Ben Salah: "Whether you like it or not, it's a legacy . . . unfortunately now closed and in ruins." Ben Ammar has described his filmmaker's role as that of "observer and subjective witness," and he takes very seriously his ethical responsibility: "As the guardian of the words of individuals I had sought out, I made it my responsibility to listen to their voices without betraying them," adding: "The boxer is by definition the incarnation of a revolt against the injustice of society. How to restore the force of his protest How to render it audible There's the challenge."
-
Dr. Shaun Lopez
Race, Place, and Football: Morocco and Egypt as "Arab Africa" in the Race to Host the 2010 FIFA World Cup
This paper examines the competition between Morocco, Egypt, and South Africa to host the 2010 FIFA Football World Cup. The decision by FIFA (football's world governing body) to award the 2010 Cup to an African nation set off a vigorous competition between these three nations to win the right to host the prestigious event. With hopes of raising the prestige, political profiles, and economic fortunes of their nations, officials from Morocco, Egypt, and South Africa constructed geographic, political, economic, and historical narratives to win over FIFA officials. This paper argues that a racial discourse was at the center of these constructions; that a discursive struggle between "Arab African" and "Black African" narratives forced FIFA officials to consider the intersection of race and geography in awarding the first World Cup to be hosted on the continent of Africa.
"Race, Place, and Football" links two seemingly disparate fields of historical research. First, it makes an important contribution to the literature on Pan-African identity. Since the 1960's, attempts to construct Pan-African unity have engendered numerous political and economic conferences. A central theme in these conferences, and in related speeches by African leaders, has been the attempt to define "Africaness" in light of the continent's linguistic, religious, phenotypic, and historical diversity. Starting with Egyptian President Gamal Abdel Nasser's attempts in the 1960's to take a leading role in Pan-African unity discussions, the authenticity of "Arabs" as Africans has been an important, if often implicit, element of disagreement between Arab North Africa and Sub-Saharan, "black" African nations. "Race, Place, and Football" links these political debates to the immensely popular cultural practice of football, and suggests that sport has played a central role in the discursive contestation of racial categories on the continent.
Second, the paper links the Arab world to the growing literature on sport and society. Despite the enormous popularity of football in the Arab World, relatively few researchers have examined the role of sport in the Arab historical narrative. This paper suggests that sport indeed has played a central role in attempts by Morocco and Egypt to define their national projects on the global stage; that racialized narratives of nationalism, modernity, and progress have been mapped on to, and promoted through, their participation in international sporting competition.